Skip to main content

Top 5 Overrated Scary Movies

Jeremy explores many topics as he juggles his passion for writing with his career as a chemical analyst and campus manager.

Horror Movie History

I've always been fascinated by scary movies; what makes some of us actually enjoy getting the bejeezus scared out of us through creepy and clever uses of the genre?

At least, that's the idea. However, horror films are often uninspired, bland, or overly reliant on gore, and they frequently land low ratings from critics. Often even the better-received films disappoint most audiences. Don't believe me? Let's examine the five most overrated scary movies and reveal suggestions for better viewing! I won't spoil any of these movies, but believe me, you'd probably be better off if I did.



5. Saw (2004)

The Premise: Two men awaken imprisoned in a bathroom. They receive terrifying instructions from mysterious mastermind Jigsaw: one must kill the other or their families will die.

Why It's Overrated: I don't mind the premise, but Saw offers one thing: gore. I'm not super squeamish, but gore only really scares me if used in conjunction with the right atmosphere. Essentially, it has to fit the story, not be used as an excuse for a lame plot. A string of disappointing sequels doesn't improve the franchise's reputation.

Saw provides stale dialogue and an implausible twist. If you're seeking torture porn, this movie has it. But there are better-written and more engaging graphic movies out there.

Instead Watch
: Want something intense but clever? Prisoners and You're Next fill the gap. The Descent also serves well if you don't mind long (but worthwhile) build ups to the action.



Psycho Noise

4. Psycho (1960)

The Premise: A woman steals money from her job and runs away, hoping to find a better life. Along the way, she stops at a motel and things take an ominous turn..

Why It's Overrated: To be clear, I don't think this classic movie is bad. It introduced the famous high-pitch violin cue, and latter portions build tension nicely. The problem is simply how boring the first half is. The main character, who you probably won't relate to since she commits embezzlement, spends too much time driving around aimlessly, contemplating her decision.

Additionally, there's an unnecessarily long scene with the psychiatrist at the end. (Even the critically panned 1998 remake knew to shorten that segment).

If you really want to see Psycho, I recommend viewing the first few minutes then skipping to the motel. Just be aware you're watching more of an atmospheric thriller than a scary movie. Is it bad? Not at all! Will it live up to its hype? Not necessarily.

Instead Watch: Honestly, Psycho 2 isn't a bad pick for a more traditional horror film. The Strangers, Don't Breathe, and Silence of the Lambs also offer unique glimpses of unhinged insane individuals. Prequel series Bates Motel is also splendidly disturbing; catch it on Neflix, how bout dat.

The Cabin in the Woods

The Cabin in the Woods

3. The Cabin in the Woods (2012)

The Premise: A group of young teenagers (of course) retreat to an isolated cabin to party and relax. However, they must face both monsters and a mysterious group operating behind the scenes.

Why It's Overrated: Honestly, maybe check this one out and decide for yourself, as it received mostly positive reception. Despite the hype, I was left underwhelmed.

The movie is part horror, but I wasn't afraid. It's also part parody, but I didn't laugh. The characters are the predictable stereotypes, and while this is done on purpose, it doesn't help endear them to you.

There's a "twist" near the end that seemed to captivate many, but frankly didn't alter my perception of the film. I wouldn't call this a terrible film, but never felt it lived up to the hype it earned.

Instead Watch: For better blends of horror and horror parody, try Scream or Shaun of the Dead.

The Exorcist

The Exorcist

2. The Exorcist (1973)

The Premise: A priest struggling with his faith must help a distraught mother expel a demon from her young daughter's body.

Why It's Overrated: The Exorcist was a marvel—for its time. It utilized impressive, for 1973, effects and helped establish the horror genre. However, by modern standards, it falls short of its cult status.

I'd label it more disturbing than frightening, and felt the climax was lackluster. This film doesn't have much to critique, as most aspects are done fine. Just fine, though—the characters, tension, and dialogue work adequately, not exceptionally.

If demons or the thought of being possessed terrifies you, maybe you'll enjoy The Exorcist. But to most viewers it just can't live up to its monumental reputation.

Instead Watch: Craving some demonic monsters? Try Lights Out, Sinister, or Insidious.

The Blair Witch Project

The Blair Witch Project

1. The Blair Witch Project (1999)

The Premise: Three friends (though they barely act like it) hear rumors of a supposed Blair Witch, and explore the woods hoping to capture it on camera.

Why It's Overrated: I've seen dozens of scary movies, and I don't think I've ever liked the protagonists less than these people. You spend the vast majority of this film watching them whine and moan as they wander lost around a forest. And not in a tension-building way; in fact, the witch is never shown on screen, and thus I never felt scared.

I hardly cared about these characters, and even if I did, the movie doesn't offer enough excitement to make it interesting. Props to Blair Witch for popularizing the found footage style, but ushering in a new series of movies doesn't automatically make Blair intriguing.

Bland horror movies bore viewers with their uninteresting stories. Blair Witch goes the extra mile and actively irritates you with its tripe and uneventful story.

Instead Watch: Paranormal Activity (I prefer the sequels) or Cloverfield if you're dead-set on the found footage genre.

Your Vote

As technology advances, so too does the realism and depth of scary movies. They may never gross as much as the latest summer blockbuster, but horror films should be around for generations to come thanks to a steady fanbase.

As we eagerly await the next best horror movie, vote for your most overrated film and I'll see you at our next creepy countdown!

Scroll to Continue

Read More From Reelrundown

© 2017 Jeremy Gill


Movie Whisperer from Moreton Bay, Queensland on June 10, 2017:

Agreed. Ive seen them all numerous times. Loved the series too to be honest.

Jeremy Gill (author) from Louisiana on June 10, 2017:

I've seen the first two! Love the Scream movies, always have interesting twists about who the killer is. And it's fun how they use scares and parody them at the same time.

Movie Whisperer from Moreton Bay, Queensland on June 09, 2017:

I love a good debate about movies! This is grreat lol. I strongly disagree on the tonal element though i must admit I havent seen cabin for a bit and you have made me want to rewatch it to continue this point haha. I see your point on the horror porody though and its one of my favourite parts of Scream. Have you seen the series?

Jeremy Gill (author) from Louisiana on June 09, 2017:


Hi Vanessa! To be clear, I'm not recommending movies with similar plots, but similar tones. Cabin in the Woods and Scream feature two very different stories, but are connected by their horror-parody elements.

It's true that Psycho and Scream both use knife-wielding killers, but the tones of the movies differ extensively, so I'd say Scream flows better with Cabin.

I give credit to Blair Witch for its clever marketing, but in terms of actual entertainment, it's one of my least favorite movies of all time. But it's fine if you enjoy it; I'm glad to hear someone got something from it!

Movie Whisperer from Moreton Bay, Queensland on June 09, 2017:

The Exorcist? Really? Instead watch lights out, Sinister or Insidious? No, no, no. Those movies arent even related to Exorcist. The Exorcist is demonic posession and there are plenty if great great demonic possession movies to list without crossing over to hauntings in Sinister and Insidious. Cabin in the Woods... meh Ill give you that but again if you want to recommend something sameish but better it shouldnt cross over to titles like Scream or Shaun of the Dead. Blair Witch... no just no, that movie started it all for found footage and will always be famous for having people think it was ACTUALLY a true story for a second with makers going as far as creating a journal to spur that idea on. No Blair Witch was great at its time of glory. Im going yo pip your instead watch on psycho too, not the same types of movies. recommendations for Stabby stabby Psycho ... maybe offering Scream here would of been better. Ugh Imma have to follow you because Saw the original was tight. The got stale as they went on but offering the instead watch offerings you list are off the mark. Ive only done one article so far but you are definitely ensuring I do some on my favourite subject very soon. Other than my debate, I like the way you write.

Jeremy Gill (author) from Louisiana on May 14, 2017:


Hey, to each their own. And overrated doesn't always means bad - I have a degree of respect for Psycho and Exorcist, I just feel they're outclassed by the best of the modern scary movies.

Any horror films not listed here strike you as overrated?

Ced Yong from Asia on May 14, 2017:

Oh dear! Other than Bleah Witch, the rest are my favourite horror flicks.

Related Articles