Original vs. Remake: The Blob (1958) vs. The Blob (1988) - ReelRundown - Entertainment
Updated date:

Original vs. Remake: The Blob (1958) vs. The Blob (1988)

original-vs-remake-the-blob-1958-vs-the-blob-1988

"Well it's kind of a - kind of a mass. It keeps getting bigger and bigger." --Steve Andrews, The Blob (1958)

That's the way Steve McQueen's character tries to describe the title creature to the police in the original version of The Blob. As a matter of fact, it isn't called the "blob" in none of the versions of the film, but instead being referred to as "monster", "thing", "parasite", and "organism", among other things. The "blob" is essentially an amorphous, jelly-like creature that slithers around devouring anything in its path, while growing in size. Aside of the original 1958 film starring McQueen, this monster has been the subject of a remake, released 30 years after. Here's a look at both films (SPOILERS included)

original-vs-remake-the-blob-1958-vs-the-blob-1988

The Blob (1958)

Released in 1958, the original film is set in rural Pennsylvania. When teenagers Steve and Jane (Steve McQueen and Aneta Corsaut) witness a meteorite crash, they go to investigate. On their way, they stumble upon an old man that ended up with a blob attached to his arm, after inspecting the meteorite. Trying to help him, Steve and Jane take the old man to Dr. Hallen's office to be treated. But what they don't know is that after leaving him there, the creature ends up devouring the old man, the doctor, and his nurse.

Having witnessed what he thinks was Dr. Hallen being killed, Steve tries to alert the authorities, only to face skepticism and disbelief. As the blob reaches the town, Steve and Jane discover what they think is the monster's aversion to cold. Steve then convinces his friends to alert the town, but not before it ends up attacking a movie theater and a dinner devouring everything in its path.

original-vs-remake-the-blob-1958-vs-the-blob-1988

The Blob (1988)

Released in 1988, the remake is set in Arborville, California. When teenagers Meg and Paul (Shawnee Smith and Donovan Leitch) go out on their first date, they stumble upon an old man with a parasite on his hand, being chased by town "bad boy" Brian Flagg (Kevin Dillon). Despite their differences, Paul and Brian agree to help the old man by taking him to the hospital. But when both the old man and Paul are devoured by the blob, Brian ends up as the main suspect.

Although Meg, having witnessed Paul's death, tries to alert everyone, she has to face the skepticism of the town and is forced to rely on Brian to help her. As the creature continues its rampage, devouring everyone at a local dinner, Meg and Brian discover that the blob is the product of a military Cold War experiment. Facing the consequences of the government cover-up, they try to warn the people while saving themselves.

Comparison of both films

 OriginalRemake

Release date

September 12, 1958

August 5, 1988

Director

Irvin Yeaworth

Chuck Russell

Writers

Kay Linaker and Theodore Simonson

Chuck Russell and Frank Darabont

Starring

Steve McQueen, Aneta Corsaut, Earl Rowe

Kevin Dillon, Shawnee Smith, Donovan Leitch

Duration

82 minutes

95 minutes

Budget

$110,000

$19,000,000

Box office

$4,000,000 (rumored)

$8,247,943 (estimated)

Jane (Aneta Corsaut) and Steve (Steve McQueen) with Dr. Hallen (Stephen Chase)

Jane (Aneta Corsaut) and Steve (Steve McQueen) with Dr. Hallen (Stephen Chase)

The Verdict

Even though I had seen the remake back in the late 80's, I didn't remember much about it. After catching the original last week, I decided to revisit the remake as well. It's important to note that the original film was an independent, low budget film that ended up becoming a surprise hit. Released in the late 50's, it is a mixture of classic horror and sci-fi, but with a certain goofiness to it. That might help appreciate the film in terms of its place in time, but it doesn't make it any less silly.

Despite of that, the film is held together mostly because of Steve McQueen, who delivers a fairly good performance on his first notable film role. He brings a certain charm and charisma to his character that keeps the film focused and afloat. The supporting cast, on the other hand, ends up feeling wooden and lifeless.

Brian (Kevin Dillon) and Meg (Shawnee Smith)

Brian (Kevin Dillon) and Meg (Shawnee Smith)

The remake was released in the late 80's, in a time when horror films and gore were the thing to do. Gone is the inherent goofiness of the original, replaced by a more serious tone focused on scaring you and making you jump. Whereas the special effects in the original were laughably bad, the ones in the remake are pretty good. Some of the deaths are gruesome and the gore is abundant.

Unfortunately, the remake lacks a lead as good as McQueen was in the original. Despite solid performances from the leads in this new version, none of them really shines. Plus the bonding between Brian and Meg feels a bit rushed and not that believable. If anything, the supporting cast is better than the original, led by Jeffrey DeMunn as Sheriff Herb Geller, and the scenery-chewing of Del Close as Reverend Jacob Meeker.

The blob coming out of the theater

The blob coming out of the theater

The blob attacks Meg at the theater

The blob attacks Meg at the theater

Another strong point for the remake is the tightness of the story. Whereas the first one featured a fairly simple story, and a sorta abrupt and lacking ending, the overall story of the remake is tighter and more fluid. In the original, the blob is thought of only as an alien creature, whereas in the remake, it's the result of a Cold War military experiment gone awry, led by a Doctor Meddows (Joe Seneca). This adds new layers to the story as the military team in charge tries to cover-up the situation by disposing of the townspeople. The remake was also very bold in its development, killing most of what seemed like the lead cast during its first half hour, and killing two kids during its climax.

However, as they delve deeper into the explanations and the nature of the blob, the film loses some of its focus. During the last half-hour, the film unravels a bit and shots itself in the foot. Plus, that last act is plagued with some inevitable 80's cheese and action-film clichés, like Brian jumping a ravine with his motorcycle, or using a bazooka to escape from the sewers, or Meg screaming silly one-liners while shooting a machine gun at the blob. Also, during the last half-hour, the special effects of the blob become more shaky and uneven. Still, I found myself impressed at how much I enjoyed it.

Dr. Meddows (Joe Seneca) and his men

Dr. Meddows (Joe Seneca) and his men

Original or Remake?

After such a write-up, the decision should be obvious. I will give this round to the remake. Although I can appreciate the original's classic sci-fi charm, the fact that I'm an 80's man plus my penchant for horror films and gore makes me lean towards the new version. Add to this the improved special effects, and a bolder story, and it's clear which one I prefer. Still, the original should be an interesting watch for any fan of horror/sci-fi films or cinema overall.

 OriginalRemake

Rotten Tomatoes

69%

59%

IMDb

6.3 /10

6.1 /10

Thief12

C

B

Nurse Kate (Lee Payton) attacked by the blob

Nurse Kate (Lee Payton) attacked by the blob

Blob Poll!

Other horror films...

Comments

Mike sarmo on November 11, 2019:

the original red dawn blob, planet of the apes, omega man, halloween, were all better

Carlo Giovannetti (author) from Puerto Rico on December 28, 2015:

Thanks for the comment! The remake was extremely effective.

Steve Sunpire from England on December 28, 2015:

The original was awesome

however 'The Blob' 1958 has many similaritys to another film called 'X the Unknown' 1956...

Personally I prefer the 1988 remake, mostly because of the ending... so creepy...

Carlo Giovannetti (author) from Puerto Rico on June 22, 2015:

Color tends to take away from a lot of black & white films. I usually try to watch films the way they were originally made.

Thanks for your comment!

PaigSr from State of Confusion on June 20, 2015:

The first one scared me the second one didn't. I also tend to lean towards the original vs the remakes. And don't get me started on the colorization...

Carlo Giovannetti (author) from Puerto Rico on March 06, 2015:

Thanks for the comment! Let me know if you ever check out the 80's version.

Stargrrl on March 06, 2015:

The Blob was a very scary movie for me back in the eighties when I was a small child. I'm talking about the 50's version. Never got around to the 80's one. Good hub.

Elizabeth Parker from Las Vegas, NV on July 19, 2013:

I definitely will. I love thrillers / horrors. Keep the reviews coming !! :)

Carlo Giovannetti (author) from Puerto Rico on July 19, 2013:

Hey, I felt the same way before I revisited the film a couple of weeks ago. I knew I had seen it, but I didn't remember much about it. I will probably review some of those other remakes you mentioned later, so keep reading :-D

Elizabeth Parker from Las Vegas, NV on July 19, 2013:

I love Horror/ thrillers. I remember loving this movie (and The Thing) when I was a kid, but I couldn't tell you any of the details about it as I haven't seen it since, so your review refreshed some of those memories! Sometimes the remakes are bad- I didn't like the Omen or Friday the 13th remakes- so I'm glad this one held some water. Voted up!!

Carlo Giovannetti (author) from Puerto Rico on July 14, 2013:

Thanks for the comments!

peachpurple, watch both films and let us know how you liked it! :-D

rose, the original has its charms and, like I said, it was an interesting watch.

FatFreddysCat, I think the film lends itself to be a lot of fun in theaters!

Keith Abt from The Garden State on July 14, 2013:

I love both versions of "The Blob," I just re-visited the 1988 remake a few months ago and it's held up pretty well (except for some of the rear-projection special effects, which have aged badly).

I saw the remake in a theater back in '88 and the audience was having a great time screaming along with the movie. It was a lot of fun.

peachy from Home Sweet Home on July 14, 2013:

Great article!! I haven't watch the blob yet, haven't heard of this movie. But I do agree that remake version is much better in sense of pictures, actions and lots of 3d effects, voted up

rose-the planner from Toronto, Ontario-Canada on July 13, 2013:

This was a great article! I should be saying The Blob from the 80s because being a Gen X kid the remake was made during my lifetime, but I am going to have to go with the original. I love the classics best. You have to admit that the original horror films are awesome because of their B Rated charm and cheesiness, lol. Thanks for sharing. (Voted Up)

-Rose